VMware

Troubleshooting vimService Creation Failed 403 in vCenter

Tapas Kumar MahantaLeave a comment

The error vimservice creation failed: error forbidden 403 during vSphere/vCenter operations typically indicates that the client cannot establish a VIM (vSphere API) session because of HTTP 403 (forbidden) conditions such as proxy interference, wrong endpoint, or access control.​

Below is a Confluence‑ready troubleshooting document.

vimService creation failed: error forbidden 403 – Troubleshooting Guide

This document explains causes and a structured troubleshooting approach for vimService creation failed: error forbidden 403 seen when deploying VCSA, adding vCenter endpoints, or using tools that talk to the vSphere API.​

Scope and symptoms

Applies to

  • VCSA deployment (UI/CLI installer) failing in Stage 1 or login step with vimService creation failed: error forbidden 403 (or similar).​
  • Third‑party or custom clients (Terraform, pyvmomi, backup tools, etc.) calling https://<vcenter_or_esxi>:443/sdk and receiving HTTP 403.​
  • Browser access to vCenter working, but thick installers or automation tools failing with 403 errors to the same vCenter/ESXi.​

Common symptoms

  • Installer/utility logs contain entries such as:
    • vimService creation failed: error forbidden 403
    • A problem occurred while logging in. Verify the connection details.​
  • vSphere Web Client/HTML5 UI may still be accessible via browser.​
  • Problem appears only from specific client machines (e.g., Windows jump host with a proxy configured).​

Root cause overview

HTTP 403 “Forbidden” indicates that the HTTP request reached the server but was rejected due to authorization, endpoint, or access policies.​

In the context of vSphere, typical root causes are:

  • Wrong endpoint or target
    • Deploying VCSA or connecting a client to a non‑vSphere server (e.g., Windows IIS, generic web server) instead of an ESXi or vCenter IP/FQDN.​
    • Using the wrong URL path or port instead of /sdk on 443.​
  • Proxy settings and man‑in‑the‑middle interception
    • Windows system/browser proxy is used by the vSphere installer; traffic goes through an HTTP proxy that returns 403 rather than forwarding to vCenter/ESXi.​
  • Access control / permissions / IP restrictions
    • vCenter restricted to specific source IP ranges or firewall rules; client address not allowed.​
    • API/service disabled or restricted on a security gateway or load balancer in front of vCenter.​
  • Authentication/authorization problems (vSphere side)
    • User has no permissions on any vCenter instance in a linked group, resulting in login denial and HTTP 403 from the UI or API gateway.​
    • Session or token issues (e.g., stale SSO session, NoPermission) causing the API gateway to respond with 403.​

Data collection

Before changing anything, gather basic info:

  1. Error details from client/installer logs
    • vCenter/VCSA installer logs (e.g., vcsa-ui-installer\logs\ or \ProgramData\VMware\ on Windows): look for vimService creation failed and surrounding lines.​
    • Third‑party tool logs (Terraform, backup, etc.) for HTTP status and exact URL.​
  2. Target details
    • IP/FQDN entered in the installer or tool.
    • Confirm whether this IP is vCenter, ESXi, or something else (IIS, reverse proxy, load balancer, etc.).​
  3. Network path
    • Whether a proxy is configured on the client (Internet Options, browser, system proxy, corporate PAC file).​
    • Firewall or WAF devices between client and vCenter.
  4. vCenter logs (if accessible)
    • Check vCenter vpxd.log and appliance reverse‑proxy logs for any 403 entries tied to the client’s IP/time.​

Step‑by‑step troubleshooting

Step 1 – Verify the target endpoint

  1. From the client machine, open a browser and go to:
    • https://<target>:443/ and https://<target>:443/sdk
    • Confirm that:
      • https://<target>/ shows vCenter or ESXi login page.​
      • https://<target>/sdk presents the vSphere Web Services SDK (XML/WSDL style page).​
  2. If you see an IIS/Apache/web‑app page instead of vCenter/ESXi, the IP or FQDN is wrong; correct it to point to vCenter or an ESXi host.​
  3. If /sdk returns 404 or 403 while the vCenter UI works via another FQDN, check:
    • Load balancer / reverse proxy configuration.
    • Whether you should use the vCenter FQDN instead of an alias.​

Step 2 – Eliminate proxy interference

  1. On Windows client where the error occurs, check proxy:
    • Internet Options → Connections → LAN settings → Proxy server / automatic configuration script.​
  2. If a proxy or PAC is configured:
    • Temporarily disable the proxy or add the vCenter/ESXi FQDN/IP to the proxy bypass list.​
  3. Re‑run the installer or client:
    • In many documented cases, disabling the proxy resolves vimservice creation failed: error forbidden 403.​
  4. For tools like Terraform or custom scripts, ensure environment variables like HTTPS_PROXY and HTTP_PROXY are unset for vCenter connections, or use no‑proxy lists.​

Step 3 – Validate DNS, certificates, and SSL path

  1. Confirm DNS resolution:
    • nslookup <vcenter_fqdn> from the client; ensure it resolves to the correct IP.​
  2. Confirm that no SSL inspection appliance is rewriting or blocking /sdk.
  3. If a reverse proxy/WAF is used:
    • Review its rules for 403 responses on /sdk or /api.​

Although certificate errors usually produce 401/SSL errors, some middleware can return 403 when certificate policies fail.​

Step 4 – Check vCenter permissions and SSO

If you hit 403 only after successful TCP/SSL connection to the correct vCenter:

  1. Try the same user in the vSphere Client (H5/HTML5 UI).
    • If login fails with messages like “Unable to login because you do not have permission on any vCenter Server systems connected to this client,” you may have 0 effective permissions and an SSO federation problem.​
  2. Review SSO and global permissions:
    • Ensure the user or group has at least read permissions on the vCenter inventory.​
    • In linked‑mode scenarios, verify that the user has permissions on at least one linked vCenter, or the client receives a denial.​
  3. Check vCenter logs for NoPermission or NotAuthenticated faults around the time of the 403:
    • These appear as vim.fault.NoPermission or NotAuthenticated in logs like vpxd.log and UI traces.​
  4. If using tokens or external identity providers, validate token audience, scope, and expiration; invalid tokens can surface as HTTP 403 in the API gateway.​

Step 5 – Review firewall and IP access restrictions

  1. Confirm that the client IP is allowed to reach vCenter on TCP 443:
    • Use telnet <vcenter> 443 or curl -vk https://<vcenter>/sdk from the client.​
  2. Check for:
    • NSX distributed firewall rules blocking this source.
    • Perimeter firewalls or load balancers configured with IP allow‑lists; unauthorized IPs can receive 403 instead of 401/timeout.​
  3. If the same operation works from another jump host or subnet, suspect IP‑based access control and adjust rules accordingly.​

Step 6 – Retest VCSA deployment / client operation

After applying fixes (correct endpoint, disabled proxy, updated permissions):

  • Re‑run the VCSA deployment wizard or client:
    • Confirm that the login step succeeds and the deployment progresses beyond the previous failure.​
  • For automation tools, re‑run plan or the API call and confirm that the HTTP status changes from 403 to 200 (or appropriate 2xx).​

Known patterns and solutions

Pattern 1 – Windows proxy causing installer 403

  • VCSA installer launched from a Windows host with corporate proxy configured in IE/Internet Options.​
  • Browser access to vCenter works through proxy, but the installer gets 403 from the proxy instead of reaching vCenter /sdk.​

Resolution:

  • Disable system/IE proxy or exclude vCenter/ESXi FQDNs from proxy.
  • Restart installer and retry; error disappears.​

Pattern 2 – Wrong target (non‑vSphere server)

  • User points VCSA installer to a Windows server or some other web server rather than an ESXi/vCenter endpoint.​
  • /sdk belongs to IIS or is missing, returning 404/403.​

Resolution:

  • Identify the correct ESXi or existing vCenter that will host the new appliance and use that IP/FQDN.​

Pattern 3 – API access forbidden for automation user

  • REST or SOAP API calls fail with 403 while UI logins succeed using another administrative account.​
  • The automation user has insufficient vCenter permissions or is blocked by IP restrictions.​

Resolution:

  • Assign the required vSphere roles/privileges to that user (or group) at appropriate scope.​
  • Confirm there is no IP allow‑list blocking the client.​
  • Always test https://<vcenter>/sdk directly from the same system that runs the installer or automation to verify connectivity and routing.​
  • Avoid using internet proxies for internal vCenter/ESXi access; where unavoidable, configure no‑proxy rules for vSphere endpoints.​
  • Standardize vCenter access FQDN and ensure DNS, certificates, and firewall rules all align with that FQDN.​
  • For automation accounts, create dedicated service principals with clearly defined roles, and test via API tools (curl/Postman/pyvmomi) before integrating into larger workflows.​

Leave a comment